Difference between Open die forging and Closed die forging:
Sr. No.
|
Open Die Forging
|
Closed Die Forging
|
1.
|
Tooling is simple.
|
Complex operation.
|
2.
|
Produces Work pieces with less dimensional accuracy.
|
Higher Dimensional accuracy.
|
3.
|
Skilled operator Required. Final shape of forging depends on skills
of operator.
|
Required Semi-skilled
operator.
|
4.
|
Process has less Reproducibility.
|
Process has more Reproducibility. Suitable for making negatives or
duplicates of each other.
|
5.
|
More material waste.
|
Relatively Reduced material waste.
|
6.
|
Low costly process.
|
Expensive process.
|
7.
|
Difficult to maintain close tolerances.
|
Easy to maintain close tolerances.
|
8.
|
Applications: Crankshafts, Shells and containers, Reactor vessels.
|
Applications: Manufacturing of connecting rod, rocker arms, gears,
shafts, Defence and aircraft industry.
|
9.
|
Also called as Smith die forging.
|
Also called as Impression die forging.
|
10.
|
Types: Hand forging, Hammer forging, press forging.
|
Types: Drop forging. Machine forging.
|
No comments:
Post a Comment